2005
THE LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY
FOR THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

(As presented)
(Minister for Children, Youth and Family Support)
Children and Young People Amendment Bill 2005 (No 2)

Contents
	Page
	1	Name of Act	2
	2	Commencement	2
	3	Legislation amended	2
	4	Section 11	2
	5	General principles
Section 12 (1)	3
	6	Section 14	3
	7	Indigenous placement principle
Section 15 (1)	3
	8	New section 15 (5)	4
	9	Members of the council
Section 36 (2)	4
	10	Principles
Section 68	4
	11	Section 151	5
	12	New section 155A	7
	13	In need of care and protection
Section 156 (1)	9
	14	Section 157	9
	15	Mandatory reporting
Section 159 (1) (i)	10
	16	New section 159 (3)	10
	17	Section 162	10
	18	Action by facilitator
Section 169 (3)	11
	19	Chief executive to report
Section 267 (4)	12
	20	Section 403 (5)	12
	21	Sections 404 and 405	12
	22	New chapter 17	19
	23	Dictionary, new definition of at risk of abuse or neglect	20
	24	Dictionary, definition of best interests principle	20
	25	Dictionary, new definition of divulge	20
	26	Dictionary, definition of facilitator	20
	27	Dictionary, definition of indigenous placement principle	20
	28	Dictionary, new definitions of information holder and in need of care and protection	21
	29	Dictionary, definition of neglect	21
	30	Dictionary, new definitions of protected information and sensitive information	21
	31	Public Advocate Act 2005, amendments 1.4 to 1.6	21

2005
THE LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY
FOR THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

(As presented)
(Minister for Children, Youth and Family Support)
Children and Young People Amendment Bill 2005 (No 2)

A Bill for
An Act to amend the Children and Young People Act 1999

    

The Legislative Assembly for the Australian Capital Territory enacts as follows:

1	Name of Act
This Act is the Children and Young People Amendment Act 2005 (No 2).
2	Commencement
This Act commences on a day fixed by the Minister by written notice.
Note 1	The naming and commencement provisions automatically commence on the notification day (see Legislation Act, s 75 (1)).
Note 2	A single day or time may be fixed, or different days or times may be fixed, for the commencement of different provisions (see Legislation Act, s 77 (1)).
Note 3	If a provision has not commenced within 6 months beginning on the notification day, it automatically commences on the first day after that period (see Legislation Act, s 79).
3	Legislation amended
This Act amends the Children and Young People Act 1999.
Note	This Act also amends the Public Advocate Act 2005 (see s 31).
4	Section 11
substitute
11	Best interests of child or young person paramount consideration
	(1)	In making a decision or taking action under this Act in relation to a child or young person, the decision-maker or person taking the action must regard the best interests of the child or young person as the paramount consideration (the best interests principle).
	(2)	This section does not apply to a decision under chapter 6 (Young offenders).
Note	A decision-maker making a decision under ch 6 about a young person or young offender must have regard to the best interests of the young person or young offender (see s 68 (aa)).
5	General principles
Section 12 (1)
omit everything before paragraph (b), substitute
	(1)	In making a decision or taking action under this Act in relation to a child or young person, the decision-maker or person taking the action must apply the following principles except when it would be contrary to the best interests of a child or young person:
6	Section 14
omit everything before paragraph (a), substitute
14	Indigenous children and young people principle
In making a decision or taking action under this Act in relation to an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander child or young person, the decision-maker or person taking the action must take into account the following:
7	Indigenous placement principle
Section 15 (1)
substitute
	(1)	In making a decision about the placement of an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander child or young person, the decision-maker must make the decision in accordance with—
	(a)	this section; and
	(b)	any indigenous cultural plan in force for the child or young person.
8	New section 15 (5)
insert
	(5)	In this section:
indigenous cultural plan, for a child or young person, means a plan to preserve and enhance the identity of the child or young person as an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander person, that is developed by the chief executive in consultation with—
	(a)	the child or young person (taking into consideration the age and maturity of the child or young person); and
	(b)	any Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander people who have an interest in the wellbeing of the child or young person; and
	(c)	any relevant indigenous organisation.
9	Members of the council
Section 36 (2)
substitute
	(2)	The Minister must ensure that there is always—
	(a)	at least 1 member who represents the interests of carers; and
	(b)	at least 1 member who represents the interests of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people.
10	Principles
Section 68
insert
	(aa)	regard must be had to the best interests of the young person or young offender;
11	Section 151
substitute
151	What is abuse?
In this chapter:
abuse, of a child or young person, means—
	(a)	physical abuse; or
	(b)	sexual abuse; or
	(c)	emotional abuse (including psychological abuse) if the child or young person has suffered or is suffering in a way that has caused or is causing significant harm to his or her wellbeing or development; or
	(d)	emotional abuse (including psychological abuse) if—
	(i)	the child or young person has been or is being exposed to conduct that is domestic violence under the Domestic Violence and Protection Orders Act 2001; and
	(ii)	the exposure has caused or is causing significant harm to the wellbeing or development of the child or young person.
151A	What is neglect?
In this chapter:
neglect, of a child or a young person, means a failure to provide the child or young person with a necessity of life that has caused or is causing significant harm to the wellbeing or development of the child or young person.
Examples of necessities of life
1	food
2	shelter
3	clothing
4	medical care
Note	An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears (see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
151B	When is a child or young person at risk of abuse or neglect?
For this chapter, a child or young person is at risk of abuse or neglect if, on the balance of probabilities, there is a significant risk of the child or young person being abused or neglected.
Examples of when a child is at risk of abuse or neglect
1	Jane is 3 months old and the chief executive has already received 5 reports about her.  Jane’s parents are long-term drug users and Jane was born with neonatal withdrawal syndrome.  Jane’s parents’ relationship is violent and, although Jane herself has not been physically harmed, she has been in her mother’s arms when her father assaulted her mother.  Police have been called to the family home a number of times because of reports of family violence.  This usually results in Jane’s parents separating for a short period then reconciling.  Jane’s mother has 3 older children from earlier relationships who are subject to care and protection orders and are being cared for by kin (under s 31 (1) (b)) because of emotional abuse from witnessing violence between their mother and Jane’s father.  Jane’s parents have agreed to work with the chief executive to address their drug use and violent behaviour.  However, they have not actually made the changes they agreed to make.  Jane’s parents do not have contact with extended family and Jane is not regularly seen by any health professionals or other community support people.  In these circumstances, the chief executive may decide that, on the balance of probabilities, there is a significant risk of Jane being abused or neglected.  Jane is therefore a child at risk of abuse or neglect.
2	Michael is 7 years old and in the full-time care of his mother.  He has never had any contact with his father.  Michael’s mother has a mental illness characterised by episodes of psychosis.  When Michael’s mother has been unwell, she has locked Michael and herself in the home for weeks at a time.  Michael sometimes says that ‘bad people’ are after him and will hurt him and his mother.  Michael’s mother attempted suicide by driving off a bridge with Michael in the car.  In these circumstances, the chief executive may decide that, on the balance of probabilities, there is a significant risk of Michael being abused or neglected.  Michael is therefore a child at risk of abuse or neglect.
3	Tom is 9 years old and is in the sole care of his father.  Since Tom was 6 years old, the chief executive has received numerous reports that Tom’s father calls him derogatory names and yells at him on a daily basis, often in the presence of other people.  Tom’s school counsellor reports that Tom appears anxious, is fearful of loud noises in the school environment and regularly cries for insignificant reasons.  Tom is assessed as being at risk of childhood depression by the school counsellor.  Tom’s father considers his parenting of Tom to be good and will not allow the chief executive to visit the family home to talk to Tom.  In these circumstances, the chief executive may decide that, on the balance of probabilities, there is a significant risk of Tom being abused or neglected.  Tom is therefore a child at risk of abuse or neglect.
4	Amy is 13 years old and regularly goes missing from home to avoid the constant fighting between her mother and stepfather. Amy is engaging in indiscriminate sexual activity and regularly consumes alcohol and illicit drugs which she pays for through prostitution.  Amy has intentionally overdosed on medication 3 times and each overdose has required medical treatment.  Amy’s parents consider that she is now making her own choices and there is nothing they can do to help her.  In these circumstances, the chief executive may decide that, on the balance of probabilities, there is a significant risk of Amy being abused or neglected.  Amy is therefore a child at risk of abuse or neglect.
Note	An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears (see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
12	New section 155A
in division 7.1.1, insert
155A	Helping families understand care and protection procedures
	(1)	A decision-maker making a decision under this chapter for a child or young person must endeavour to ensure that the relevant people for the decision—
	(a)	understand what the decision is going to be about; and
	(b)	understand the decision-making process; and
	(c)	know that the child or young person and people with parental responsibility for the child or young person may take part in the decision-making process and have their views and wishes heard; and
	(d)	are informed of, and understand, the decision.
	(2)	The chief executive must give the relevant people for the decision sufficient information about the decision-making process, in language and a way that they can understand, to allow the child or young person, and people with parental responsibility for the child or young person to take part fully in the decision-making process.
	(3)	In this section:
relevant people, for a decision for a child or young person, means—
	(a)	the child or young person or, if the child is represented, the representative of the child or young person; and
Note	Representation of children and young people is further dealt with in s 23 and s 24.
	(b)	a person with parental responsibility for the child or young person.
	(4)	This section is subject to any order of a court.
Note 1	A child or young person has a right to take part in a proceeding under this Act in relation to the child or young person (see s 22).
Note 2	A court must also take steps to ensure that the child or young person and other people understand proceedings etc (see s 408).
13	In need of care and protection
Section 156 (1)
substitute
	(1)	For this chapter, a child or young person is in need of care and protection if—
	(a)	the child or young person—
	(i)	has been abused or neglected; or
	(ii)	is being abused or neglected; or
	(iii)	is at risk of abuse or neglect; and
	(b)	no-one with parental responsibility for the child or young person is willing and able to protect the child or young person from suffering the abuse or neglect.
14	Section 157
substitute
157	Incident need not have happened in ACT
	(1)	This section applies if a person believes that a child or young person is in need of care and protection under section 156 because the child or young person—
	(a)	has been abused or neglected; or
	(b)	is being abused or neglected; or
	(c)	is at risk of abuse or neglect.
	(2)	It does not matter whether conduct giving rise to the belief happened completely or partly outside the ACT.
15	Mandatory reporting
Section 159 (1) (i)
substitute
	(i)	a public servant who, in the course of employment as a public servant, works with, or provides services personally to, children and young people or families; or
16	New section 159 (3)
insert
	(3)	Subsection (2) does not apply to a person if the person reasonably suspects that—
	(a)	someone else has made a report to the chief executive about—
	(i)	the same child or young person; and
	(ii)	the same abuse or injury; and
	(b)	the other person has reported the same grounds for their suspicion as the person has for their suspicion.
17	Section 162
substitute
162	Chief executive must record reports
The chief executive must make and keep a written record of—
	(a)	each report made to the chief executive under section 158 (Voluntary reporting) or section 159 (Mandatory reporting); and
	(b)	each child protection appraisal made because of a report mentioned in paragraph (a).
162A	Records about authorised carers to go to public advocate
	(1)	This section applies if—
	(a)	the chief executive receives a report about a child or young person under section 158 (Voluntary reporting) or section 159 (Mandatory reporting); and
	(b)	at the time of the incident that gave rise to the report—
	(i)	the chief executive had parental responsibility for the child or young person; and
	(ii)	someone else (the authorised carer) was exercising the chief executive’s parental responsibility for the child or young person under section 31 (Authorisation to exercise parental responsibility for particular child or young person); and
	(c)	the incident that gave rise to the report involved the authorised carer.
	(2)	As soon as practicable after making a record under section 162 (a) about the report, the chief executive must give a copy of the record to the public advocate.
18	Action by facilitator
Section 169 (3)
omit everything before paragraph (c), substitute
	(3)	A facilitator may do anything necessary or convenient to be done in relation to facilitating a conference (whether or not the conference actually takes place), including, for example, all or any of the following:
	(a)	prepare for the conference, including, for example—
	(i)	meeting with people; and
	(ii)	consulting with people with knowledge of or experience in a particular culture; and
	(iii)	providing mediation; and
	(iv)	resolving conflicts;
Note	An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears (see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
	(b)	asking a person to give information or a report to a conference without inviting that person to be a participant at the conference;
19	Chief executive to report
Section 267 (4)
substitute
	(4)	A report under this section for a final care and protection order for a child or young person must be given—
	(a)	each year; or
	(b)	if the order is in force for less than 1 year—at least 1 month, but not earlier than 2 months, before the order expires.
20	Section 403 (5)
substitute
	(5)	This section expires on 1 December 2006.
21	Sections 404 and 405
substitute
404	When is information divulged?
In this chapter:
divulge includes communicate.
405	Who is an information holder?
For this chapter, a person is an information holder if—
	(a)	the person is or has been—
	(i)	the chief executive; or
	(ii)	the public advocate; or
	(iii)	an official visitor; or
	(iv)	someone else exercising a function under this Act; or
	(v)	someone else engaged in the administration of this Act; or
	(b)	the person has been given information under this Act by a person mentioned in paragraph (a).
Note	Protected information may be given to people under various provisions of this Act, including:
·	s 29 (Power to give and receive information)
·	s 45 (Assistance for public advocate)
·	s 73 (Powers of court in relation to reports)
·	s 162A (Records about authorised carers to go to public advocate)
·	s 405H (Information may be given in best interests of child or young person).
405A	What is protected information?
	(1)	For this chapter, information is protected information if it is information about a person that is disclosed to, or obtained by, an information holder because the person is, or has been, an information holder.
	(2)	Without limiting subsection (1), protected information includes sensitive information.
405B	What is sensitive information?
	(1)	For this chapter, information is sensitive information if it is—
	(a)	child abuse information; or
	(b)	child abuse appraisal information; or
	(c)	interstate child abuse information; or
	(d)	family group conference information; or
	(e)	information prescribed by regulation for this section.
	(2)	In this section:
child abuse information means information—
	(a)	in a report (a child abuse report) made under—
	(i)	section 158 (Voluntary reporting); or
	(ii)	section 159 (Mandatory reporting); or
	(b)	in a record (a child abuse record)—
	(i)	made under section 162 (a) (Chief executive must record reports); or
	(ii)	that relates to a notification under the Children’s Services Act 1986, section 103 (as in force at any time); or
	(c)	that would allow information in a child abuse report or child abuse record to be worked out; or
	(d)	that identifies a person who made a child abuse report or would allow the identity of the person to be worked out.
child abuse appraisal information means information—
	(a)	in a record (an appraisal record) of a child protection appraisal made because of a child abuse report; or
	(b)	that would allow information in an appraisal record to be worked out.
interstate child abuse information means information—
	(a)	in a report (an interstate child abuse report) made under a provision of a law of a State corresponding (or substantially corresponding) to section 158 or section 159 that is provided to the chief executive under a provision of the law of the State corresponding (or substantially corresponding) to—
	(i)	section 29 (Power to give and receive information); or
	(ii)	section 323 (Disclosure of information); or
	(b)	that would allow information in an interstate child abuse report to be worked out; or
	(c)	that identifies a person who made an interstate child abuse report or would allow the identity of the person to be worked out.
family group conference information means—
	(a)	information about anything said or done in a meeting, or for mediation or conflict resolution, under section 169 (3) (a) (Action by facilitator) for a family group conference (whether or not the conference actually takes place); or
	(b)	information, or information in a report, given under section 169 (3) (b) for a family group conference (whether or not the conference actually takes place); or
	(c)	information in a signed agreement under section 172 (Agreements arising from conferences); or
	(d)	information in a record under section 173 (Outcome of conference); or
	(e)	information about anything said or done at a family group conference including information given in a report to the family group conference; or
	(f)	information that would allow information mentioned in paragraphs (a) to (e) to be worked out.
405C	Offence—secrecy of protected information
	(1)	An information holder commits an offence if the information holder—
	(a)	makes a record of protected information about someone else; and
	(b)	is reckless about whether the information is protected information about someone else.
Maximum penalty:  50 penalty units, imprisonment for 6 months or both.
	(2)	An information holder commits an offence if the information holder—
	(a)	does something that divulges protected information about someone else; and
	(b)	is reckless about whether—
	(i)	the information is protected information about someone else; and
	(ii)	doing the thing would result in the information being divulged to someone else.
Maximum penalty:  50 penalty units, imprisonment for 6 months or both.
	(3)	This section is subject to the following sections:
	(a)	section 405D (Exception—information given under this Act);
	(b)	section 405E (Exception—information given under another law);
	(c)	section 405F (Exception—information given with agreement).
405D	Exception—information given under this Act
	(1)	Section 405C (1) does not apply to the making of a record of protected information if the record is made—
	(a)	under this Act; or
	(b)	in the exercise of a function, as an information holder, under this Act.
	(2)	Section 405C (2) does not apply to the divulging of protected information if the information is divulged—
	(a)	under this Act; or
	(b)	in the exercise of a function, as an information holder, under this Act.
Note	Various provisions of this Act provide for protected information to be given to people, including:
·	s 29 (Power to give and receive information)
·	s 45 (Assistance for public advocate)
·	s 73 (Powers of court in relation to reports)
·	s 162A (Records about authorised carers to go to public advocate)
·	s 405H (Information may be given in best interests of child or young person).
405E	Exception—information given under another law
	(1)	Section 405C (1) does not apply to the making of a record of protected information if—
	(a)	the information is not sensitive information; and
	(b)	the record is made—
	(i)	under another territory law; or
	(ii)	in the exercise of a function, as an information holder, under another territory law.
	(2)	Section 405C (2) does not apply to the divulging of protected information if—
	(a)	the information is not sensitive information; and
	(b)	the information is divulged—
	(i)	under another territory law; or
	(ii)	in the exercise of a function, as an information holder, under another territory law.
Note	Other legislation may provide for information to be given to people, including:
·	Freedom of Information Act 1989, s 10 (Right of access) (but see s 38)
·	Health Records (Privacy and Access) Act 1997, s 10 (Statement of principle regarding right of access) (but see s 14).
405F	Exception—information given with agreement
Section 405C (2) does not apply to protected information if the information—
	(a)	is not sensitive information; and
	(b)	is about a person; and
	(c)	is divulged with the person’s agreement.
405G	Giving protected or sensitive information to a court
	(1)	An information holder need not divulge protected information, that is not sensitive information, to a court unless it is necessary to do so for this Act or another territory law.
	(2)	An information holder need not produce a document containing protected information, that is not sensitive information, to a court unless it is necessary to do so for this Act or another territory law.
	(3)	An information holder need not divulge sensitive information to a court unless it is necessary to do so for this Act.
	(4)	An information holder need not produce a document containing sensitive information to a court unless it is necessary to do so for this Act.
	(5)	In this section:
court includes a tribunal, authority or person with power to require the production of documents or the answering of questions.
produce includes allow access to.
405H	Information may be given in best interests of child or young person
	(1)	The chief executive may give someone protected information (including sensitive information) about a child or young person if the chief executive considers that the giving of the information is in the best interests of the child or young person.
	(2)	A facilitator may give the chief executive protected information (including sensitive information) about a child or young person if the facilitator considers that the giving of the information is in the best interests of the child or young person.
Note	A person who is given information under this section must comply with s 405C (Offence—secrecy of protected information).
22	New chapter 17
insert
Chapter 17	Transitional
418	References to public advocate
	(1)	In this Act:
public advocate includes a person who is, or has at any time been, the community advocate under the Community Advocate Act 1991, as in force at any time.
	(2)	Subsection (1) is a law to which the Legislation Act, section 88 (Repeal does not end effect of transitional laws etc) applies.
419	Expiry—ch 17
This chapter expires on the day the Public Advocate Act 2005, section 3 commences.
23	Dictionary, new definition of at risk of abuse or neglect
insert
at risk of abuse or neglect, for chapter 7 (Children and young people in need of care and protection)—see section 151B.
24	Dictionary, definition of best interests principle
substitute
best interests principle—see section 11 (1).
25	Dictionary, new definition of divulge
insert
divulge, for chapter 15 (Confidentiality and immunity)—see section 404.
26	Dictionary, definition of facilitator
substitute
facilitator means a person who is appointed as a facilitator under section 166.
27	Dictionary, definition of indigenous placement principle
omit
28	Dictionary, new definitions of information holder and in need of care and protection
insert
information holder, for chapter 15 (Confidentiality and immunity)—see section 405.
in need of care and protection, for chapter 7 (Children and young people in need of care and protection)—see section 156.
29	Dictionary, definition of neglect
substitute
neglect, for chapter 7 (Children and young people in need of care and protection)—see section 151A.
30	Dictionary, new definitions of protected information and sensitive information
insert
protected information, for chapter 15 (Confidentiality and immunity)—see section 405A.
sensitive information, for chapter 15 (Confidentiality and immunity)—see section 405B.
31	Public Advocate Act 2005, amendments 1.4 to 1.6
omit

Endnotes
1	Presentation speech
	Presentation speech made in the Legislative Assembly on	2005.
2	Notification
	Notified under the Legislation Act on	2005.
3	Republications of amended laws
	For the latest republication of amended laws, see www.legislation.act.gov.au.

© Australian Capital Territory 2005